The four formulas
Each starts at 5 feet (60 inches) and adds a fixed amount for every inch above it:
| Formula | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Devine (1974) | 50 kg + 2.3 kg per inch | 45.5 kg + 2.3 kg per inch |
| Robinson (1983) | 52 kg + 1.9 kg per inch | 49 kg + 1.7 kg per inch |
| Miller (1983) | 56.2 kg + 1.41 kg per inch | 53.1 kg + 1.36 kg per inch |
| Hamwi (1964) | 106 lb + 6 lb per inch | 100 lb + 5 lb per inch |
Where they came from
Hamwi's rule appeared in a 1964 book chapter on diabetes diets, as a quick bedside estimate. Ten years later, B.J. Devine published his version in a paper on dosing the antibiotic gentamicin, where doctors needed a body weight that ignored fat. It spread through hospital pharmacy, and it's still used to dose some drugs today. Robinson and Miller published revised versions in 1983, also in pharmacy journals.
None of them were designed to tell you what you should weigh. They don't know how much muscle you carry, how big your frame is, or how old you are.
Why they disagree
For a man who is 5 ft 10 in (10 inches over 5 feet):
- Devine: 50 + 23 = 73 kg
- Robinson: 71 kg
- Miller: 70.3 kg
- Hamwi: 166 lb, or 75.3 kg
For a woman who is 5 ft 4 in, they run from 54.4 kg (Hamwi) to 58.5 kg (Miller). The spread grows for very tall and very short people, because each formula adds a different amount per inch. Below 5 feet, they weren't designed to work at all.
A better reference: the healthy BMI range
The weights that give a BMI of 18.5 to 24.9 at your height make a wider band that fits more body types. At 5 ft 10 in (1.778 m), that's 18.5 × 1.778² = 58.5 kg to 24.9 × 1.778² = 78.7 kg. All four formulas land inside it. If you're muscular, you may sit above it and be perfectly healthy; seewhat BMI can and can't tell you.
Sources
- Devine BJ. "Gentamicin therapy." Drug Intell Clin Pharm 1974;8:650-655.
- Robinson JD, Lupkiewicz SM, Palenik L, et al. "Determination of ideal body weight for drug dosage calculations." Am J Hosp Pharm 1983;40(6):1016-1019.
- Miller DR, Carlson JD, Lloyd BJ, Day BJ. "Determining ideal body weight (and mass)."Am J Hosp Pharm 1983;40(10):1622-1625.
- Hamwi GJ. "Therapy: changing dietary concepts." In: Danowski TS, ed. Diabetes Mellitus: Diagnosis and Treatment. American Diabetes Association; 1964:73-78.
- World Health Organization. Technical Report Series 894 (2000), table 2.1.